{ "updated": "2026-10-09T21:16:26.064772+00:00", "models": [ { "key": "hailuo-max", "name": "Hailuo 3 Max", "actualUSD": 10.236544, "videoGenerationUSD": 10.16, "automatedReviewUSD": 0.076544, "paidRetakesUSD": 0, "rejectedRequests": 0, "pending": 0, "unknownReservationUSD": 0, "paidVideoRequests": 18, "requestedGenerationSeconds": 127, "actualReturnedSeconds": 131.958333, "finishedSeconds": 95, "usdPerFinishedMinute": 6.4652, "nativeSources": [ { "take": "hailuo-max-m02r", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 10.125, "samples": 243, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 10.176, "samples": 318 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-d02", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.216, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-d01", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.216, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-d03", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 14.375, "samples": 345, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 14.432, "samples": 451 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-d04", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.216, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-d05", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.216, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m01", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.216, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m03", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 12.25, "samples": 294, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 12.288, "samples": 384 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m04", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.583333333333333, "samples": 158, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 6.624, "samples": 207 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m05", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.583333333333333, "samples": 158, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 6.624, "samples": 207 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m06", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 12.25, "samples": 294, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 12.288, "samples": 384 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m07", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.583333333333333, "samples": 158, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 6.624, "samples": 207 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m08", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.583333333333333, "samples": 158, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 6.624, "samples": 207 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m09r", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 8.0, "samples": 192, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 8.032, "samples": 251 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m11", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.216, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m12", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.216, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m01v", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 768.0, "height": 1344.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.216, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "hailuo-max-m13", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 7.291666666666667, "samples": 175, "width": 1344.0, "height": 768.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 7.328, "samples": 229 } ] } ] }, { "key": "h3", "name": "MiniMax H3", "actualUSD": 15.503802, "videoGenerationUSD": 15.47, "automatedReviewUSD": 0.033802, "paidRetakesUSD": 0, "rejectedRequests": 0, "pending": 1, "unknownReservationUSD": 2.12, "paidVideoRequests": 17, "requestedGenerationSeconds": 119, "actualReturnedSeconds": 123.958333, "finishedSeconds": 95, "usdPerFinishedMinute": 9.7919, "nativeSources": [ { "take": "h3-m02r", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 10.125, "samples": 243, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 10.157, "samples": 318 } ] }, { "take": "h3-d02", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.19865625, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m01v", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 1440.0, "height": 2560.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.19865625, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "h3-d01", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.19865625, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "h3-d03", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 14.375, "samples": 345, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 14.407, "samples": 451 } ] }, { "take": "h3-d04", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.19865625, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "h3-d05", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.19865625, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m01", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.19865625, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m03", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 12.25, "samples": 294, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 12.282, "samples": 384 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m04", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.583333333333333, "samples": 158, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 6.61534375, "samples": 207 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m05", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.583333333333333, "samples": 158, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 6.61534375, "samples": 207 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m06", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 12.25, "samples": 294, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 12.282, "samples": 384 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m07", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.583333333333333, "samples": 158, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 6.61534375, "samples": 207 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m08", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.583333333333333, "samples": 158, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 6.61534375, "samples": 207 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m11", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.19865625, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m12", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.166666666666667, "samples": 124, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.19865625, "samples": 163 } ] }, { "take": "h3-m13", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 7.291666666666667, "samples": 175, "width": 2560.0, "height": 1440.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 7.32365625, "samples": 229 } ] } ] }, { "key": "flux", "name": "FLUX.3 Video", "actualUSD": 24.186636, "videoGenerationUSD": 24.14, "automatedReviewUSD": 0.046636, "paidRetakesUSD": 2.55, "rejectedRequests": 0, "pending": 0, "unknownReservationUSD": 0, "paidVideoRequests": 20, "requestedGenerationSeconds": 142, "actualReturnedSeconds": 142.833333, "finishedSeconds": 95, "usdPerFinishedMinute": 15.2758, "nativeSources": [ { "take": "flux-m02r", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 10.041666666666666, "samples": 241, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-d02", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.041666666666667, "samples": 121, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.023219954648526, "samples": 217 } ] }, { "take": "flux-d01", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.041666666666667, "samples": 121, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.023219954648526, "samples": 217 } ] }, { "take": "flux-d03", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 14.041666666666666, "samples": 337, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 14.023219954648527, "samples": 604 } ] }, { "take": "flux-d04", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.041666666666667, "samples": 121, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.023219954648526, "samples": 217 } ] }, { "take": "flux-d05", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.041666666666667, "samples": 121, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 }, { "type": "soun", "duration": 5.023219954648526, "samples": 217 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m01", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.041666666666667, "samples": 121, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m03", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 12.041666666666666, "samples": 289, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m04", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.041666666666667, "samples": 145, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m05", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.041666666666667, "samples": 145, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m01v", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.041666666666667, "samples": 121, "width": 704.0, "height": 1280.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m02r-r02", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 10.041666666666666, "samples": 241, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m06", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 12.041666666666666, "samples": 289, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m07", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.041666666666667, "samples": 145, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m08", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 6.041666666666667, "samples": 145, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m09r", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 8.041666666666666, "samples": 193, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m11", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.041666666666667, "samples": 121, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m12", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.041666666666667, "samples": 121, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m13", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 7.041666666666667, "samples": 169, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] }, { "take": "flux-m12-r02", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.041666666666667, "samples": 121, "width": 1280.0, "height": 704.0 } ] } ] }, { "key": "seedance", "name": "Seedance 2.5", "actualUSD": 1.16523, "videoGenerationUSD": 1.16523, "automatedReviewUSD": 0.0, "paidRetakesUSD": 0, "rejectedRequests": 1, "pending": 0, "unknownReservationUSD": 0, "paidVideoRequests": 1, "requestedGenerationSeconds": 5, "actualReturnedSeconds": 5.041667, "finishedSeconds": 0, "usdPerFinishedMinute": null, "nativeSources": [ { "take": "seedance-empty-room-diagnostic", "tracks": [ { "type": "vide", "duration": 5.041666666666667, "samples": 121, "width": 1280.0, "height": 720.0 } ] } ] } ], "historicalBaseline": { "key": "baseline", "name": "Earlier Kling + HeyGen", "scope": "Historical 05-01 v001 picture workflow plus v002 scored-mix review; reused for this comparison", "actualUSD": 14.340458, "historicalUSD": 14.340458, "incrementalComparisonUSD": 0, "videoGenerationUSD": 14.242, "automatedReviewUSD": 0.098458, "paidVideoRequests": 21, "finishedSeconds": 95, "usdPerFinishedMinute": 9.0571, "breakdown": [ { "name": "Kling 3.0 Pro", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "requests": 16, "actualUSD": 12.992 }, { "name": "HeyGen Avatar IV", "model": "heygen/avatar-iv", "requests": 5, "actualUSD": 1.25 }, { "name": "Automated reviews, including scored mix", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "requests": 4, "actualUSD": 0.098458 } ], "sources": [ "chapter-05-section-01-v001/planning/cost-snapshot.json", "chapter-05-section-01-v002/planning/cost-snapshot.json", "production/cost-ledger.json" ], "receipts": [ { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-d03", "model": "heygen/avatar-iv", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.7 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m12", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.56 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-performance-review", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.016172 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-d01", "model": "heygen/avatar-iv", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.15 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-d02", "model": "heygen/avatar-iv", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.2 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-d04", "model": "heygen/avatar-iv", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.1 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-d05", "model": "heygen/avatar-iv", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.1 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m01", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.56 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m01v", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.56 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m02", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 1.12 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m03", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 1.344 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m04", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.672 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m05", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.672 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m06", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 1.344 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m07", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.672 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m08", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.672 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m09", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.896 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m10", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.56 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m11", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.56 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-full-review", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.039324 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m02r", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 1.12 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m09r", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.896 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-m13", "model": "kwaivgi/kling-v3.0-pro", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.784 }, { "name": "CH05-S01-v001-repair-review", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.0274 }, { "name": "CH05-music-v001-05-01-mix-review", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "status": "completed", "actualUSD": 0.015562 } ], "exclusions": [ "Original audiobook production, supplied Suno music, unmetered built-in image generation, local labor/compute, subscriptions, software and storage are separate.", "Both delivery formats count once; reused footage adds no generation cost.", "Discarded paid attempts and automated reviews are included." ] }, "newComparisonRecordedUSD": 51.092212, "alignmentRevision": { "updated": "2026-10-09T21:16:26.064772+00:00", "models": [ { "key": "hailuo-max", "name": "Hailuo 3 Max", "firstPassUSD": 10.236544, "alignmentPassUSD": 0.04838169, "cumulativeUSD": 10.28492569, "cumulativeUSDPerMinute": 6.495743, "unconfirmedReserveUSD": 0, "newFootageRequests": 0, "requests": [ { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-hailuo-max-d01-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 3.888e-05, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-hailuo-max-d02-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 0.000308333333333, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-hailuo-max-d03-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 0.000108, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-hailuo-max-d04-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 0.0001296, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-hailuo-max-d05-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 3.888e-05, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-hailuo-max-full-AV-review", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "cost": 0.047758, "status": "completed" } ] }, { "key": "h3", "name": "MiniMax H3", "firstPassUSD": 15.503802, "alignmentPassUSD": 0.04088152, "cumulativeUSD": 15.54468352, "cumulativeUSDPerMinute": 9.817695, "unconfirmedReserveUSD": 2.12, "newFootageRequests": 0, "requests": [ { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-h3-d01-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 3.888e-05, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-h3-d02-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 3.888e-05, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-h3-d03-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 0.00036, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-h3-d04-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 3.888e-05, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-h3-d05-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 3.888e-05, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-h3-full-AV-review", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "cost": 0.040366, "status": "completed" } ] }, { "key": "flux", "name": "FLUX.3 Video", "firstPassUSD": 24.186636, "alignmentPassUSD": 0.04844546, "cumulativeUSD": 24.23508146, "cumulativeUSDPerMinute": 15.306367, "unconfirmedReserveUSD": 0, "newFootageRequests": 0, "requests": [ { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-flux-d01-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 3.76125e-05, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-flux-d02-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 3.76125e-05, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-flux-d03-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 0.0001050075, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-flux-d04-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 3.76125e-05, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-flux-d05-native-ASR", "model": "openai/whisper-large-v3", "cost": 3.76125e-05, "status": "completed" }, { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-flux-full-AV-review", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "cost": 0.04819, "status": "completed" } ] }, { "key": "kling-heygen", "name": "Kling + HeyGen", "firstPassUSD": 14.340458, "alignmentPassUSD": 0.047002, "cumulativeUSD": 14.38746, "cumulativeUSDPerMinute": 9.086817, "unconfirmedReserveUSD": 0, "newFootageRequests": 0, "requests": [ { "name": "CH05-COMP-v002-kling-heygen-full-AV-review", "model": "google/gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "cost": 0.047002, "status": "completed" } ] } ], "incrementalUSD": 0.18471067, "method": "Existing footage re-edited. Paid transcription and automated review only. Original costs and unknown reservations retained. Local editing labor/compute unpriced." } }